Call Ahead for Guaranteed Freshness
At Koepsel's Farm Market, we believe that nothing beats the taste of our homemade pie, made with love, and the finest ingredients! Our daily bakery delights Door County visitors and locals alike with fresh-baked pies made from treasured family recipes passed down through generations.
Want to ensure your favorite pie is waiting for you? We strongly encourage our customers to call ahead and place your pie orders at least one day before pickup. This simple step guarantees that we'll have your pie fresh-baked in the morning and ready when you arrive!
Whether you're planning a family gathering, special celebration, or simply craving our famous Door County cherry pie, calling ahead ensures you won't be disappointed.
(920) 854-2433
Our Signature Pies - $17.99 Each
Available Daily (In-Store till we're out & Pre-order)
- Door County Cherry Pie - Made with authentic Door County cherries
- Apple Pie - Classic comfort with perfectly spiced apples
- Peach Berry Pie - A delightful blend of sweet peaches and berries
- Strawberry Rhubarb Pie - The perfect balance of sweet and tart
- Caramel Apple with Walnuts - Rich caramel and crunchy walnuts elevate this classic
Pre-Order Only
- Raspberry Pie - Bursting with fresh raspberry flavor
- All Berry Pie - Blackberry, Blueberry, Raspberry, Cranberry
- No Sugar Cherry Pie - The best Door County Cherry Pie, without the added sugar!
- Peach Pie - Fresh summer peach bursting with flavor
- Blueberry Pie - The tastiest fresh blueberry flavor
Seasonal Specialties
- Rhubarb Pie - Available until Mid June
- Pumpkin Pie - Available after Labor Day
Frozen Take-and-Bake Pies
Available daily in store till we're out
- Door County Cherry Pie
- Apple Pie
- Peach Berry Pie
- Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Perfect for bringing home that fresh-from-the-oven experience whenever you're hungry!
Planning Large Orders?
For bakery orders beyond individual pies, we recommend calling at least one day ahead. This allows us to prepare your order with the same care and attention to quality that has made Koepsel's a Door County tradition for over 65 years.
Ready to place your order? Call us today to reserve your slice of Door County tradition!
Remember: Our pies are made fresh daily using time-honored family recipes. Call ahead to guarantee availability and ensure your perfect pie experience at Koepsel's Farm Market.
